So this happened today…
Now before I go into my tirade about the Scituate Middle school, let me preface it by saying that I am NOT a mom who coddles here kids. I am a hard-ass mom who believes in teaching her kids the natural consequences to their actions. I am also a mom that is real about how her kids can act. I don’t make excuses….EVER. Having said that, JT has in the past been a kid in elementary school that was a bit of a joker. If he had an audience he’d perform, but this year, his grades and report card indicates otherwise. Yet, old habits die hard, so maybe he did something but as evidenced by not only the text I’m showing but our lengthy conversation, he had NO idea why he received this detention.
So, I call the school. The admin assistant picks up and says that the principal will call me back in a few minutes. She never does….. I sit down to check my email and I see this:
Mrs. Twiggs,
John’s name was mentioned in a conversation with the teacher covering Mrs. Derosiers ELA class on January 15.
As per the Apollo team policy which states that if a substitute leaves a student’s name for disciplinary reasons, he was assigned a detention for Monday February 4th.
First of all, she didn’t ask why I called, she simply assumed the reason for my call AND furthermore, I asked for a return phone call, not an ambiguous email. Professionalism 101 Dr. N!
Heated, I hit the keyboard with this response:
Dr. Napolitano,
I was hoping that you would call me back so we could have a conversation, as I have more questions regarding this situation.
First of all, if JT deserves detention for doing something wrong, then I agree, that he should face the consequences. However, as both you and I know, leading child development experts tell us that consequences for children need to be (a) natural, (b) logical, and (c) timely in order to be effective. Clearly, this is not a timely consequence for his action and makes no sense to punish a kid for something that happened over 2 weeks ago.
Furthermore, he has no recollection of what the offending behavior was. Once again, detention is NOT the natural or logical consequence for a behavior that he has no recollection committing.
Believe me, education is the TOP priority in our household and I only expect respectful behavior of my children. Furthermore, I know my son more than you think and I know he is a kid who does talk too much and gets silly. That is beside the point….
When the “policies” are not clear to both parent and student, and the communication between school and parent is poor, how can we expect the student to correct any behavior? Consistency is key, is it not?
I asked JT recall any and all times that he would deserve detention to which he was very honest. He tried to recall any possible time when he may have deserved detention in vain, but could not think of any time. He only remembers receiving a yellow slip 2 or 3 times (which to my knowledge is related to being unprepared) and one blue slip. Also, he stated that he thinks the yellow slip policy re-sets every semester. Regarding the blue slip and my email last week, if my son is in fact “out of control” I would expect the Scituate Middle School to communicate with me immediately by phone so we could remedy the situation. Again, the behavior system that Scituate Middle School makes absolutely no sense to me at all and is inconsistent at best.
I have my written notes from the meeting at the end of the last school year and there are no notes where parents were given an explanation of the behavior system. In addition, I would have attended the open house, but the because of the lackluster communication of the Scituate Middle School and the several corrections about corrections, I was unable to make appropriate arrangements for my other children and rearrange my schedule. I, too, work full time as a high-school teacher, raise a family of three, and I’m in the process of obtaining my masters. Though I appreciate the daily announcement emails, I would appreciate if the important emails about times like open house and safety incidents at school were communicated clearly and timely.
In my estimation, a simple name “mention” from a substitute is not sufficient to warrant detention over TWO WEEKS later, especially when the specifics of the incident were not made clear to the child. Great job teaching our kids about accountability, not!
Having expressed my extreme displeasure, I will still go forward with JT’s detention on Monday because I want him to realize that if in fact, he did do something wrong, he must face the consequences, but I am less than pleased about the way things have been handled in several circumstances this year.
I would appreciate a response from you with a detailed description of the behavioral expectations and systems so I can review them with my son because clearly, the Scituate Middle School has failed my son in this capacity.
Regards,
Angela M Twiggs
So, I eagerly wait for my response. Needless to say, this year with the Scituate Middle School has been egregiously frustrating. This is not the first incident of poor communication about both health and safety issues.
I’m trying really hard to keep it in perspective. After all, I am in the trenches too, but you bet your ass if I’m having a difficult time with a student, the parent is the FIRST member of the learning team that I call.
The saga continues….